Glock vs. XD(m) and S&W M&P

[SigPro09]

To each his own! I have mine reduced so I can't really tell the difference, even before I had it reduced the "collateral impact" that you speak of didn't affect me like it does some, then again I don't have super small hands. I like 10mm with an RMR because the long distance with a pistol becomes a breeze.

I get what your saying though.

Yup, I have a G30, so a G29 would seem a natural alternative, but not for everyone:
- Size in the hand
- Size in the holster
- Cost of Ammo'
- Implications if you load your own ammo'
- Implications if for whatever reason lead ammo' is desirable to you

Best,

Nick

[leadpersuasion]

If you were considering the 1911, you also might wanna consider the FNH FNP-9 or 40. It has the SA/DA of the 1911 that you might want without the price point. I personally love my Glock 19. With the new Gen. 4 Glocks coming out, the ability the get the proper grip is a nice feature and with so many parts, you can tune a Glock to your preference. The S&W and XD(m) are nice, but have less custom options in the aftermarket.

[EGSMachine]

i sot the G21 and the M&P 45 back to back. the grip suited me better on the M&P. i shot better with it. the M&P grip feels slightly slimmer in girth and comes with additional backstraps. love it. 350 rounds so far and i can't complain.

[amadeus76]

Decide to go with a XDm in 9mm... Probably get a Glock somewhere down the road as well. Thanks to all for their input!

[RayMich]

Decide to go with a XDm in 9mm... Probably get a Glock somewhere down the road as well. Thanks to all for their input!

Which one did you get?

4.5 or 3.8 full size, or 3.8 compact.

I'm hoping to get the 3.8 compact to go along with the full size.

[NoBucks]

Since I got my 3.8 Compact my 4.5 has sat in the gun safe. Sometimes, at night, I think I can hear the 4.5 sobbing softly.

[amadeus76]

Which one did you get?

4.5 or 3.8 full size, or 3.8 compact.

I'm hoping to get the 3.8 compact to go along with the full size.

I went with the 4.5...

[Base Bleed]

Congrats.
You will find it to be a very dependable gun.

That being said, I'm considering dumping mine and getting a regular XD for continuity with the XO's choice. And her trigger is way better than my XDm...go figure.

[WVShooter]

I own an XD in .45ACP and have shot an M&P .45ACP.
I loke both guns and almost bought an M&P but chise the XD.
It feels better, more accurate,(both for me anyway) and holds more rounds than the M&P.

[Old Guy]

I like the XD platforms because they mimic the 1911 grip angle the best and fit my hand well. However, as mentioned above, shoot all of them and then choose what fits you the best. As to caliber, that too is a personal choice as to what you are comfortable with and cost.